Here, As Well As There: Nida Fazli’s Poem on the Suffering which Unites Us

It is easy to find ideas and practices that divide us, superficial markers like ‘caste’ or ‘religion’ that allow us to brand somebody as ‘The Other’. Nida Fazli did the opposite; even in loss and suffering, he showed us that the plight of the ordinary man is perhaps our biggest unifier. The fight then, is not against this imaginary ‘Other’ but against the people who exaggerate our differences.

Nida Fazli (1938-2016) was an eminent Urdu poet and lyricist. During the partition his parents migrated to Pakistan, but a young Fazli decided to stay back in India. He moved to Mumbai at an early age and ended up composing many memorable songs for the film industry.

Fazli revolted against the elite and stylistic forms of Urdu and Hindi, favouring instead, a simpler colloquial language that would speak to everybody. He embraced and wrote all forms of poetry including ghazals, nazms, dohas and songs.


He composed many lines on the brutality of the politics which manufactured religious fanaticism and eventually led to the partition. He emphasized the need to focus instead, on the struggles, both social and philosophical, of people who were trying to come to terms with loss and displacement.

After his first visit to Pakistan, Fazli was struck by the idea that people’s suffering and its articulation was similar on both sides of the border. He thus composed the following lines:

Insaan me haivaan yahan bhi hai wahan bhi
Allah nigehbaan yahan bhi hai wahan bhi

Khoonkhaar darindo ke faqat naam alag hain
Shehron mein bayabaan yahan bhi hain wahan bhi

Rahman ki rahmat ho ya bhagvan ki murat
Har khel ka maidaan yahan bhi hai wahan bhi

Hindu bhi mazay se hain aur muslmaan bhi mazay se
Insaan pareshaan yahan bhi hai wahan bhi

Uthta hai dil-o-jaan se dhuaan dono taraf se
Ye Mir ka divan yahan bhi hai wahan bhi


The beast within the human is here, as well as there

Allah is the protector here, as well as there

Only the names of blood-thirsty monsters are different
Wastelands within cities exist here, as well as there

The Hindus are at peace and so are the Muslims
Only people are distressed here, as well as there

Whether it is the blessings of Rahman or the idols of Bhagvan
All these games have an arena here, as well as there

Smoke rises from the hearts and souls on both sides
Mir’s* court is assembled here, as well as there

*Mir Taqi Mir (18th century poet) is widely revered as the foremost Urdu poet. He wrote the following lines which are echoed by Fazli: “Dekh toh dil ki jaan se uthta hai, ye dhuan sa kahan se uthta hai” (See whether this smoke arises from the heart or the soul).


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *